Methodology
Every ranking on the site is a formula. Here's what goes in and what comes out.
Where the data comes from
We scrape listings from every major DVC resale broker on a regular cadence. Each listing is parsed into a normalized record: resort, use year, annual points, years remaining on the deed, ask price, points available by year, and broker-listed closing fees when the broker publishes them.
Resort dues per point come from the annual dues statements published by the condo associations. We keep a per-resort, per-year table and the scoring always uses the most recent year we have on file.
When the same contract is listed at more than one broker, we dedup: we keep the cheaper of the two as canonical (and prefer an Available one over a Pending one) and show the other broker as "Also at: <broker>" on the card and on the listing detail page. The listing count on the homepage and the "N listings" header on /listings counts distinct contracts, not duplicates.
Lifetime Cost per Point
The single most useful number on the site. Captures what one point of this contract will cost you over its remaining life, at today's dues rate:
Lifetime Cost / pt = (ask + closing fees + other costs + Disney admin fee) / lifetime points + current annual dues per point
Closing fees use the broker's own fee schedule when we know it (sliding-scale, tiered, or flat), and fall back to a $700 default plus $150 other costs otherwise. The Disney admin fee is $500. These defaults are overridable per contract on the calculator.
Lifetime points isn't just annual × years. When a contract's current-use-year points are listed on the broker page, we use them directly for the near-term years and only multiply out the future ones. A stripped contract (current year = 0 pts) gets fewer lifetime points than the same annual-point contract with its full current year intact, and the math reflects that.
True Lifetime Cost per Point
Same formula, but compounds annual dues at 4% per year. That's our best estimate of the long-run average based on public DVC dues disclosures over the last decade. 3% was the industry- standard placeholder; we moved to 4% in November 2026 to match what has actually been happening. You can see the 2025 and 2026 figures on the dues history page; more historical years are on the roadmap.
True Lifetime Cost / pt =
(ask + closing + other + admin
+ sum over y = 1..years_remaining of
( dues_now × (1.04)^y × annual_points ))
/ lifetime pointsUse Lifetime Cost to compare contracts at the same resort today, and True Lifetime Cost when comparing across resorts. The growth rate matters more at long-deed resorts than short-deed ones.
Deal score
The pill next to each listing is a stable measure, not a percentile rank. We compute how far below the resort's current median purchase cost per lifetime point the ask is. Purchase cost means ask + closing fees + Disney admin fee divided by the contract's total lifetime points; it leaves annual dues out so a short-deed resort and a long-deed resort get judged on the same scale.
deal_score (%) =
round(
(median_purchase_cost − this_purchase_cost)
/ median_purchase_cost × 100,
1
)
≥ 20% → Exceptional
≥ 10% → Great
≥ 5% → Fair value
≥ 2% → Near market
± 2% → At market
< -2% → Above marketWorked example. Say the median purchase cost per lifetime point for Boardwalk Villas today is $4.20. A Boardwalk listing whose per-point purchase cost works out to $3.70 scores about 12% below median → Great. One at $4.15 scores about 1% below → At market. One at $4.80 scores about -14% → Above market.
Why absolute discount and not a percentile rank: in a slow week any middling listing can crack the 90th percentile. Absolute discount keeps the language of the pill honest. "15% below median" means the same thing regardless of how many listings cleared this week. The median is recomputed with the rest of the scoring pipeline on each scrape cycle.
Resale restrictions
Three resorts carry Disney's post-January-2019 resale restriction: Riviera, Villas at Disneyland Hotel, and the Cabins at Fort Wilderness. Resale points at those resorts can only book that same resort, and resale points purchased at the Original 14 resorts after that date cannot book these three. We surface this as a chip on every card and a full callout on the listing detail page. Direct-purchase owners are unaffected; the restriction applies only to resale.
Listing lifecycle: Available, Pending, Sold
- Available. Appeared on the broker's site in our most recent scrape.
- Pending. Was Available but didn't come back in this scrape. Usually means the broker moved it to a pending-sale queue.
- Sold. Either confirmed by the broker, or auto-expired after 60 days in Pending (if a listing hasn't resurfaced on the broker's site in two months, we assume it sold and stop ranking it).
What we don't claim
- We don't have actual sold prices. All comparisons use ask prices. A listing priced well below median could still negotiate up, and a well-above-median listing could close lower. We ride that uncertainty every time we rank.
- Dues growth isn't guaranteed. 4% is our best estimate, not a promise. True Lifetime Cost is a projection, not a quote.
- Our dedup is keyed on the broker's listing ID. Two brokers can list the same physical contract under different IDs and we wouldn't catch it. We're working on cross-broker fuzzy matching.
- We only rank live listings. We don't publish historical sold prices; those aren't public data.
Questions or corrections? Email hello@dvcpixiedust.com or see contact.